Idols Power Ranking: No. 11

1. wow!! i love kathrine mcphee. she is awesome

Brittany at 10:03AM on Dec 27th 2007

2. Great to see her on the list! But i'd put her above a few more people, I don't think she should be close to number one, but she has a lot of things coming up in the new year. And SOTR/MD was the number two selling single of 2007 (it was number 2 in 2006 as well)

Katie at 2:51PM on Dec 27th 2007

3. mcphee rocks! she should be higher tho. infront of Blake, Elliott, Kellie, and Jordin.

i mean especially Blake. c'mon people. hes done nothing.
kat has had 3 hot 100 hits, the number 2 best selling single of 2006, and 2007.

kirk at 3:25PM on Dec 27th 2007

4. Wow, these people really didn't do their research, I could add about 20 things in there that Katharine Mcphee has done post-idol, but whatever.

T at 6:33PM on Dec 27th 2007

5. omg she wasnt that good

KATiEx3 at 6:35PM on Dec 27th 2007

6. Katharine should actually be higher than several others on this list. In fact, right now her "Q" rating is probably higher than any of the other Idols except for Carrie and perhaps Kellie. In other words, if you showed her picture to the average person on the street, a higher percentage of people would recognize her than all but maybe two on this list. The girl is everywhere. But congratulations to all of these Idols. They all deserve to be here, and they're all very good at what they do. And, most important, they're all good people.

Brentwood at 11:45AM on Dec 28th 2007

7. You are right she is not that good. Her CD tanked basically. She has done a lot of stuff to get her face in the news, not much to do with music. She has a beautiful voice, but little range when challenged.

She's good but..... at 12:43PM on Dec 28th 2007

8. i don't really like her

cass at 5:23PM on Dec 28th 2007

9. She is okay. But Chris Daughtry is so much better~!!!!

Rhonda at 8:14PM on Dec 28th 2007

10. I agree with many other bloggers -- she's not that good (or likable either)! Flirting is not a talent.

krussrn at 8:14PM on Dec 28th 2007

11. Wow, I definitely think Katharine deserves to be up higher on the list...I'd put her in at #5 or #6. She's accomplished a lot more than ending up on "hot chick" charts. AOL needs a better research team.

Jasmine at 8:54PM on Dec 28th 2007

12. I'm sorry, but Katharine McPhee is in no way better than Carrie Underwood. Carrie has a great voice and a lot of class. Katharine is really not that good. How she beat out Chris Daughtry, I'll never know....

Annie at 9:00PM on Dec 28th 2007

13. kat is awsome

kim at 9:07PM on Dec 28th 2007

14. when kat sang over the rainbow she was awsome!! she has a beautiful voice !

kim at 9:11PM on Dec 28th 2007

15. Katharine McPhee is a beautiful girl!!!! But I like her with long brown insted of short blond hair dont you???

Lindsey A.S at 9:55PM on Dec 28th 2007