We Call BS: Carrie Calls Jessica Fat

PopEater
posted: 332 DAYS 12 HOURS AGO
comments: 13
Text SizeAAA
(Sept. 5) -- Here at PopEater, we take pride in calling them like we see them. While we'd love to believe that Carrie Underwood called Jessica Simpson fat, we're going to go ahead and declare shenanigans on the OK! story claiming such.
OK!, quoting an always-reliable "pal" of Underwood, says she laughed at Simpson's recent PEOPLE cover, "because it's the same one Jess did about John Mayer ? same smile, same look, except she's a little fatter." Would an Underwood "pal" really do her catfighting dirty work like this? We see it as doubtful, hence, the BS declaration.
Skip over this content

Cat Fight

    Jessica Simpson and Carrie Underwood are becoming quick rivals, as the two continue to trash talk each other and fight about whether Tony still keeps in contact with his ex.

    Getty Images / AP

    OK! exclusively reported in May, Tony still contacts Carrie. "They talk and text regularly," a source tells OK!. "They broke up as friends, so there's no reason for them not to talk."

    Chris Walter, Wire Image

    "I looked at his call log," Jessica told listeners during an Aug. 20 interview with a Nashville radio station. "Tony and I both laughed" at Carrie's assurstions that she still talks to Romo. "We got a chuckle out of it," Jessica said.

    Rick Diamond, Wire Image

    A friend of Carrie Underwood tells OK!, "She's livid that Jessica would feel the need to publicly try and embarrass her when it's Jessica who should be embarrassed. Her boyfriend is calling Carrie behind her back!"

    X17online.com

    Another source admits that Carrie is adding fuel to the fire, "Carrie thinks Jess is a big bottle of bleach and a pair of high-heeled cowboy boots trying to ride off of the fame of Newlyweds." Ouch!

    Edward A. Ornelas, San Antonio Express-News/ZUMA Press

    Romo and Simpson celebrate Romo's 28th birthday with a kiss at a Dallas nightclub in April.

    Robert Hart, ZUMA Press

    The NFL quarterback and singer, seen here enjoying Romo's birthday cake, first started dating in November.

    Robert Hart/ZUMA Press

    Romo and Simpson cheer a three-point shot by the Dallas Mavericks in a game against the Los Angeles Lakers in March.

    Ron Jenkins, Fort Worth Star-Telegram/MCT

Skip over this content

Skip over this content

We Call BS

    In August, we called BS on a Page Six report claimingJustin Timberlake and Britney Spears were set for a duet. Shortly after, Timberlake denied it. Status: Win

    FilmMagic (2)

    When News of the World claimed Lindsay Lohan and supposed lover Samantha Ronson were set to tie the knot, we easily called BS. We'll wait til they admit they're a couple before buying any nuptial rumors. Status: Pending

    Tom Briglia, FilmMagic

    In a double-dose of calling BS, OK! and Star hit us in the same week with some terribly unbelievable Aniston rumors. A week later, Jen and John Mayer split. Status: Win

    OK! / Star

    When a "pal" of Carrie Underwood supposedly told OK! that Jessica Simpson looks "fatter" in her latest PEOPLE cover than the last, we called BS. Status: Awaiting denial

    Getty Images / AP

2008 AOL LLC. All Rights Reserved.
2008-09-05 08:21:47