Ellen DeGeneres is replacing Paula Abdul on 'American Idol,' after the 'Straight Up' singer quit her job this past August, but but the initial reaction to the news is that PopEater readers aren't thrilled.

When asked if the talk show host would be a good replacement for Abdul, 55 percent of PopEater voters say no. Furthermore, when questioned if they thought it was fair that the singers would be judged by someone with no musical background, they answered that it was unfair.