Silly Parents, These Movies Aren't for Kids
By Brenna Ehrlich Posted Nov 30th 2009 01:00PM
'Where the Wild Things Are' is scary. Surprise. What did you expect, given the title of the movie and macabre nature of the majority of director Spike Jonze's films--not to mention the dark quality inherent in every single one of 'Wild Things' author Maurice Sendak's books? Even before Jonze's film came out, everyone was buzzing about how Warner Brothers balked at the dark touches the 'Being John Malkovich' director added to the narrative: truly terrifying tantrums thrown by Max, the main character, shouting matches between the imposing Wild Things and a cacophonous soundtrack by the Yeah Yeah Yeahs' Karen O. It's as if no one has ever made a challenging children's movie before. Well, PopEater did some digging and came up with a list of 10 flicks to match, if not rival, 'Where the Wild Things Are' in cinematic sophistication. Check out our rundown!
'The Wizard of Oz'
'The Wizard of Oz'
Although this 1939 candy-colored flick was based on a children's novel and is jam-packed with catchy songs, whimsical creatures and important lessons (there really is no place like home), 'The Wizard of Oz' is, in a word, terrifying. Between the house falling on the witch, the flying monkeys and the creepy (false) rumors about the Munchkin hanging himself during filming, 'Oz' kept many a child sleeping with the lights on for decades afterward.
'Willy Wonka and the Chocolate Factory'
Based on a book by the Grand Master of Scaring Kids Witles, Roald Dahl, 'Willy Wonka' is basically a parable about being a good kid. Charlie -- the poor lad -- triumphs over a mewling cadre of sinners (children who embody qualities like greed, gluttony and sloth) and is rewarded for his Algerian ethics in the end when he inherits a chocolate factory. That would all be well and good if said sinners were not horrifically punished over the course of the movie, their downfall heralded by a group of singing creatures called Oompa-Loompas. Forget the Boogey Man, just tell your screaming brats that Willy Wonka is watching.
'The Nightmare Before Christmas'
Back when Tim Burton first released this stop-action animation cult classic, Disney didn't even want its name associated with the macabre flick, according to ign.com. Instead, the studio released the film under its Touchstone Pictures banner. Apparently, Disney thought 'The Nightmare Before Christmas' was too scary for tots--and they thought right. Packed with singing skeletons, dead pets and a group of monsterous children who torture Santa Claus, the movie tells the tale of Jack Skellington, king of Halloweentown, who aims to get into the Christmas spirit. More suited for midnight showings at the local indie cinema than pre-naptime fare, 'The Nightmare Before Christmas' became a hipster fave over the last decade or so, even coming to be released in 3D.
'The Labyrinth'
This star-studded film was also based (at least loosely) on a Maurice Sendak book, the lesser-known 'Outside Over There,' which tells the story of Ida, whose baby sister is spirited away by goblins. Featuring Jennifer Connolly as 15-year-old Sarah, David Bowie (hell, yeah!) as the Goblin King and a host of puppets created by director Jim Henson and executive producer George Lucas, 'The Labyrinth' is a dark coming-of-age story that transports a young girl into a world filled with evil goblins and sexual confusion. From the Goblin King's efforts to seduce Sarah to the sheer tightness of Bowie's trousers, there's a lot of perplexing adult feelings pulsing through this film. Also, the kick-ass soundtrack (entirely sung by Bowie) is more appropriate for rocking out at a loft party than for singing a fussy kid to sleep.
'The Princess Bride'
Based on thoroughly confusing book by William Goldman--the tome purports to be an abridged version of a fictional book by a nonexistent dude named S. Morgenstern--'The Princess Bride' is at once a classic love story and a Mel Brooks-esque comedy. The film opens with a sick child sullenly tolerating his grandfather, who attempts to amuse the boy by reading him a fairytale--the story of a poor farm boy and his lost love, Buttercup. Although the ensuing tale is most definitely the stuff of myth and legend--there's princesses, giants and castles galore--it actually cleverly satirizes your garden-variety "happily-ever-after" schtick.
'The Dark Crystal'
'The Dark Crystal' is one of those films that you saw as a child that you can't quite recall much about except that it gave you nightmares. Another Henson creation, the movie takes places on some distant planet where they're myriad beings jostling for prominence--prominence that depends, apparently, on whether or not a crystal of some kind is intact or not. Rather than try to explain the intricate chaste systems and unique obstacles inherent in this fictional world, we're going to suggest you watch this clip. Those vulture things are just freaking creepy.
'The Neverending Story'
Based on a longer, creepier book by the same title (are you sensing a trend, here?), 'The Neverending Story' was panned by the New York Times when it was released in 1984. Dubbed ''The Pre-Teen- Ager's Guide to Existentialism'' by the reviewer, the film admittedly beats the symbolism drum a little more loudly than most kids' movies: A boy named Bastian begins reading a book about a mythical land called Fantasia in which an evil force called 'The Nothing' threatens to destroy everything, including the Ivory Tower where 'The Childlike Empress' dwells. Obviously, the story is some parable about the loss of childhood, hope, imagination, etc, etc. Still, despite the caterwauling of the NYT, it's managed to take a respectable place in the canon of cinematic classics--those films that one watches even after the children's section at the DVD store is off-limits.
'Jumanji'
Another cinematic adaptation of a children's book, 'Jumanji' is full of horrors both realistic and surreal. First, Alan Parrish (played by Robin Williams) is sucked into a board game back in 1969, only to be released decades later into an unfamiliar world by a pair of orphans. Let's just let that sink in--the film stars orphans. The trio is then forced to continue playing the demonic game, which releases all manner of horrors: crushing vines, stampeding animals, and, to top it all off, a man-hunting dandy who wants to add Parrish to his collection of mounted and stuffed beasts. No wonder kids have summarily denounced Monopoly in favor of video games.
'Hook'
Robin Williams seems to have been typecast as the man who refuses to grow up (see the above flick as well as 'Jack' and horrorshows like 'Patch Adams'), and he played his most literal Peter Pan syndrome role to date when he starred in 1991's 'Hook.' Although Peter Pan is essentially a children's story (if you ignore all the pedophila rumors about J.M. Barrie), it was a dark story even in its earliest incarnations. There's man-eating crocs, evil pirates and wicked fairies, as well as Pan himself--a consummate rogue who taught generations of women to fall in love with the developmentally challenged bad boy.'Hook' takes the tale a step further, wandering from the kiddie pool into the deep end by exploring the life of the ultimate Lost Boy after he reaches adulthood. Although slightly saccharine with its lessons about embracing your inner youth and spending time with your children, 'Hook' manages to appeal to the the nightcap-drinkers as well as the nightcap-wearers. Also, Dustin Hoffman as Captain Hook is just epic.
'Flight of the Navigator'
To explicate why this movie is terrifying to children, let's just take a look at the plot as described by Wikipedia: '[Twelve-year-old] David is abducted by an alien space craft in 1978. Due to time dilation, David is gone for only a few hours, but when he is returned to Earth, it is 8 years later in 1986. Everyone else on Earth has aged eight years, but David is still physically twelve years old.' Damn. Getting abducted by aliens is bad enough, but to be stuck in a 12-year-old's body when everyone else is almost legal? That sucks.
- Filed under:
- Gut Reactions -
- Movie News -
- Videos
celebrity one-stops
-
Jennifer Aniston
Is it Brad(ley) and Jen take 2? Jen was spotted out on the town with dreamboat ...
-
Paris Hilton
After Fairly Legal actress, Sarah Shahi, laid into Paris via Twitter for almost...
-
Kate Middleton
Kate Middleton is officially a princess. She walked the aisle in an Alexander...
-
Denise Richards
According to Denise, she's not sure that her estranged ex is completely sober....
Popeater Hot Topics
FOX 411
FEED- Break Time: NFL star gets tons of wedding gifts
- Helen Mirren dresses like Queen Elizabeth, grants sick child's wish to meet royality
- 'Dancing with the Stars': Is Kellie Pickler the best winner ever?
THR
FEED- USA Orders Family Comedy Pilot From 'Fairly Legal' Producer
- Netflix's Ted Sarandos Reveals His 'Phase 2' for Hollywood
- TV Ratings: 'Dancing' Rises in Finale, 'Voice' Dips, 'SYTYCD' Steady With Premiere
Access Hollywood
FEED- Brandi Glanville Claims She Hooked Up With Gerard Butler
- Charlie Sheen Talks Ladies – Onscreen & Off
- Jonah Hill ‘Overwhelmed’ By ‘Moneyball’ Supporting Actor Nomination
POPEATER HERE, THERE & EVERYWHERE
Sites We Love

- Break Time: NFL star gets tons of wedding gifts
- Helen Mirren dresses like Queen Elizabeth, grants sick child's wish to meet royality
- More From Foxnews.com
- Abercrombie & Fitch Meets with Eating Disorder Association, Promises More Sensitivity
- Jamie-Lynn Sigler: My Heel-Wearing Days Are Dwindling
- More From PEOPLE.com

- Arrested Congressional Development
- Watch As Long Island Ravers Turn This Train Car Into The Worst Place On Earth
- An Ode To Guy Fieri's Goatee
- More From Buzzfeed
Live from Microsoft's New Generation Xbox event!
Xbox Reveal liveblog on Joystiq
Dozens Killed in Oklahoma Tornado; Death Toll to Rise
Justin Bieber Booed, Gets Standing Ovation at Billboard Music Awards
2013 Billboard Music Awards Best and Worst Dressed
Watch: Kansas Meteorologist Seeks Shelter From Tornado
Xbox One architecture panel liveblog!
Selena Gomez Leaving Justin Bieber's House: Booty Call Rumors Swirl
Two Pilots Fired After Brazilian Pop Star Takes Captain's Seat Mid-Flight


Add a comment
This writer has such a mish-mosh of movies above and not the best reasoning.
Scary is not the issue: social redeeming value is. OZ has lots of it. NIGHTMARE BEFORE CHRISTMAS smacks of the slick sell in Hollywood, "Daw, it's like scary-mixed-with-holiday. It'll sell, ruff ruff."
Social redeeming value: What leaves you with the potential to be more insightful, more empathetic, more visionary after viewing/reading. Nobody wants to discuss social redeeming value anymore because it starts too many arguments. That doesn't mean we should forget about it.
Reply
You are right but the problem is that few are willing to accept ANY norms. I agree The Wizard of Oz has social redeeming values but here are just a few of the objections I have heard to it:
1) Little people are stereotyped
2) Monkeys are demonized
3) Suggests home is where your family is, which is hurtful to those with no families
4) All the main characters are white men
5) Most are happy that two witches are killed, not a good message for kids
6) Suggests that spinsters are awful people, a sexist lie
And ofc the main reason most parents object to these movies is because they think the world must cater to a very narrow definition of what is acceptable to children so they, the parents, don't have to do any work, i.e. research the movies and if the children see them, actually TALK to their kids about what the movies are saying and why.
Why do people have this strange idea that kids movies have to be all soft and squishy and sweet?
Kids *LIKE* scary. They always have, hopefully they always will.
"not to mention the dark quality inherent in every single one of 'Wild Things' author Maurice Sendak's books?"
Huh? Yeah Little Bear is absolutely FRIGHTENING! What a stupid review. I can't believe I wasted 30 seconds of my life reading this stupidity!
Reply
"Dustin Hoffman as Captain Hook is just epic."
Loved the line, "To a 10 year old , I'm huge."
Reply
this is just stupid. some of these are my favorite movies that i have been watching since childhood. you just have to know what scares your kids & what doesn't. teach your children to distinguish fantasy from reality....
or just tell them not to be little punk b*tches! lol....
Reply
LOL, exactly
No kidding...I watched half of those movies before I was in middle school. So freaking what?
This list is ridiculous. I watched all these movies as a child and they are all great. People are way too over protective and need to stop sheltering their children. Most of the issues raised by the author are overlooked by children anyway. Oh and not mention the fact that the author cites wikipedia. Charlie for "Willy Wonka" was not an orphan either, this site gets all its info mixed up on every list they ever do. Horrible list, enough said
Reply
In Labyrinth, Jennifer Connelly played Sarah, not Ida. It was her baby brother, Toby, not her baby sister who was kidnapped by the Goblin King.
Reply
Go read it again. The first few lines talked about the book that the movie was based on.
Another scary one that looked like it was for kids was Radio Flyer, with Elijah Wood and Joseph Mazzello. It looks like a movie about brothers building a wagon that flys, but instead, it's about their desperate attempt to escape child abuse.
Reply
If the writer of this article really saw Willie Wonka or read the book she would know that Charlie is NOT an orphan.
Reply
damn people, not only had i watched most of these movies by the time i was 12, but i had moved into the realm of true horrot flicks, friday the 13th, the exorcist, damien(which really freaked me out and had most of the guys in my dorm checking for numbers on our scalps. oh i went to boarding school) and worse.
Reply
that was not the scary part of willie wonkathe scary part was when they were on the boat and Willie started going on the rampage
Reply
Seriously??? My 8 & 10 year old girls have watched ALL of those movies & MORE...the Grudge...Drag Me To Hell (just today after school with me!! They are well adjusted, athletic, & honor roll students! We go on FAMILY vacations & they think it's a HUGE treat to have a babysitter as they always go with us! Both girls will see New Moon as they have seen Twilight. They know it's all FAKE! Good grief! Adults screw things up for everyone! Get a life people! Very sad!
Reply
Give me a break! Ok, ok I'll calm down. Could it be possible that the people in their 30's and up who are in psychiatric hospitals and jails were really traumatized by MOTHER GOOSE??? If you only knew the tales behind those little rhymes...
My sister and I also watched Looney Toons back in the late 60's and 70's. Those were never made for kids, but after our stints in various prisons and hospitals, we turned out pretty well! heehee Perhaps the problems with some of the teenagers and young adults began after watching too many episodes of Ren and Stimpy? And don't forget SpongeBob....why he is corrupting our children as we speak! Hope everyone had a great Thanksgiving!
;)
Reply
I agree. The Wizard Of Oz and Willy Wonka scared me when I was a kid and I refuse to watch them now. I'm surprised they didn't mention all the "Disney Classics" Phuleez. You can't convince me that the wicked witch didn't scare the bejeebers out of you? Kids movies my foot. I think adults LOVE to scare little kids. And it worked.
Reply
you were awfully sensitive. counseling MIGHT help
The wicked witch wasn't near as scary as her monkeys in my opinion.