Ellen DeGeneres began her run on 'American Idol' as the replacement judge for Paula Abdul.

In her two episodes, we saw Ellen take her place next to Simon at the judges' table, and watched as she critiqued her way through the gruesome Hollywood week.

What did PopEater readers think about her first days on the job? Is she better suited for her talk show or 'Idol'? Does her spot on the singing competition make you more likely to watch?

Find out how our readers voted inside. And watch the Girls on Pop take on DeGeneres below.