Simon Cowell: Howard Stern Not 'Idol' Material

By Bryan Alexander Posted Feb 19th 2010 02:48AM

Add Simon Cowell to the list of people not thrilled with the rumor that Howard Stern could fill his spot on 'American Idol.'

Stern doesn't have the experience to sit in his seat, the exiting judge Cowell said yesterday.

"You've just got to know what you're talking about," Cowell said, according to the Daily News. "We have to have people on these shows who actually know what they're talking about, rather than just guessing. They've really got to have experience, so that they can not just criticize, but offer constructive advice as well."

Cowell was "fairly certain" Stern hasn't been approached by 'Idol' producers to fill the spot when he leaves the show to host his own 'X Factor' show. The Stern 'Idol' rumor has run rampant on the Internet and has been partially fanned by the radio show host himself.

Cowell also said Madonna would not make a great replacement due to time commitments. Cowell said he doesn't think a big name like Madonna could manage that.

"The good news for [the producers] is that there's no shortage of candidates," Cowell said.

But he wouldn't pick a favorite to take the spot as America's favorite music truth-teller.

"You're never going to pick anyone as good as you are, are you?" Cowell joked. "That's why I don't think anybody [at Fox] really asks me that question."

Comments

(150)

Friday 19 February

By Notstern

Highest Rank Vote down Vote up Report this

Stern has no business wanting to be an Idol judge. It's gross.

By mrgmorgan56

Lowest Rank Vote down Vote up Report this

Give me a break. Idol is for brainless twits. Anyone is qualified for the show...including Simon Cowell.

By Gigi

It's all a much needed PR stunt. It draws attention to the show. It fuels the flames to keep the viewers more curious. Controversy sells.

By Jim

Jezz,, where do you begin with this show? You have a lesbian (scouting for her own kind of special talent), a couple of no talent hacks and simon, now you want stern?! Man, I feel sorry for all those kids that truly have talent and deserve a break. These clowns are screwing up a good thing. At least Paula had talent of her own, although wacked out most of the time.

By zepfan1944

Jim - You can't be serious! No talent hacks? Randy Jackson played bass for Journey, Kara DiaGuardi (not sure if I spelled it right) is a successful songwriter, Simon Cowell produced many artists, and if you've ever paid attention to Ellen's own show, she absolutely loves music and singers, male & female. She simply is not just looking for someone 'with her own kind of special talent.' Research the people you talk about before you condemn them.

Monday 22 February

By Brad

Vote down Vote up Report this

Because Ellen has so much experience in music....what a bunch of idiots.

"Ellen LOVES Music!!!" This might be the most narrow-minded opinion I have ever seen. Stern has been involved radio and rock music for over 30 years.

By Donna

If he makes it as a judge I wont be watching it!

Saturday 20 February

By Jeanne

I couldn't agree more!! I will never watch the show again, should Howard Stern slime his way into the chair!

By SecretPact

I have to say Paula Abdul is not missed on A.I. However, I feel strongly that Simon will be missed. Certainly, Howard Stern is not the man to replace Cowell. Stern just doesn't have "it", and alienates too many people. It would be a disaster if Stern were on the show. Besides, he makes enough money on Sirrius/XM radio. I have an idea. Why not hold auditions for the next A.I. judge?

By valeskas

What about Ryan Seacrest as a judge and some other person for the job he has right now.

By Samantha

I agree, "hold auditions." Let's be fair & those auditions should be 'judged' by the fans. Maybe, just maybe, the right person will win the replacement....OR, maybe he/she will win because the fans aren't voting for the best, ONLY the ones they like because of how they look, dress, smile, or how many records they've sold. All in all, like AI, the best doesn't always win.

By realist

stern is a out dated, washed up tool

By hughjassoliii

Don't worry, Bucko. He wouldn't take the pay cut to work on 'Idol'. Outdated and washed-up while making 100 million a year. Say what?

By michael mcgowen

2 words jamie fox

By JJRR

Offer it to Barbra Streisand. The industry genius in music, acting, directing & producing. Who better than someone with the superior talents, longevity & perfection like no other.

By Garry

Barbra Streisand would never work out...all the idol winners would have to be bleeding heart liberals.

By Josie

I have to totally agree with Simon. Howard Stern is not American Idol material. I know that some people don't like Simon, but I think that he does know what he is doing. He is a good judge. A little out there sometimes with his statements, but he does get the contests to try harder and make better song choices and get there desires going. I don't want him to leave. I also think that Ellen is a good replacement.

Sunday 28 February

By Jean Clark

Howard Stern is the bottom of the barrel. He's vulgar("COARSENESS OF MANNER,offensive,etc."

By Marianne

Wow Jamie Foxx, what a great idea

By chicobombico

Stern should dry up and blow away. He is a piece of human trash.

Page 1 of 8