VH1 Gets Out of the Trash TV Business

In an unexpected move, VH1 is scrapping the majority of its lineup and starting from scratch. The network recently revealed the most comprehensive slate of original programming in its history, and missing are the very franchises that helped transform the one-time purveyor of music videos into a (much-watched) three-ring circus of "celebreality" and sometimes crass dating shows.
"I think it was really just part of our evolution. We're a pop culture network by definition, so we do always have to be molding and moving," Jeff Olde, executive vice president of original programming and production at VH1, tells
PopEater exclusively. "We've had such a great run, and really had a blast with all those shows, but it just felt like, 'OK, what's the next thing gonna be?'"
VH1 will unveil a total of 44 original series before the end of the year. Each series is expected to fall into one of three categories: music, celebrity and "real life stories." "We're expanding the ways we tell a story so that we have more ways to reflect on what's happening in the music and pop culture that our viewers love," Olde says of the network's new direction.
Olde notes that the staff at VH1, who he feels reflect the net's audience, was largely responsible for the overhaul. "Our audience is also a lot of the people who work at the network. There's especially a lot of twentysomething women. And I swear every one of them was having a baby or they were getting married, and I thought we're missing an opportunity here ... It was like a light bulb went off, and we thought, we need to be in this place also. Because I always want the network, in addition to being this fun place to go, to feel relevant. And the challenge with our team is to pick those life moments and put them in really engaging and entertaining types of formats so they have that VH1 flavor to them."
The new shows are being developed to appeal to VH1's target audience, which it is calling "Gen Mix," a demo composed of "young adults who make up the tail-end of Generation X and the very beginning of Gen Y or the Millennials" -- that is, those ranging in age from about 25 to 34.
"It really came down to zeroing in on who our audience is, where they are in their life and what things are important to them. And we pulled some things out that felt great," Olde says. "Let's try to see if we can take our brand of storytelling and our way of connecting with culture and tap it into real life issues for our viewers. Because it just felt like it would be more substantive and yet we could still have a great time."
VH1 is also painting the change-up as a return to the network's roots -- the net's original moniker was Video Hits One -- with 40 percent of the new programming focusing on music. This includes the return of stalwart programs like 'Behind the Music' and 'Storytellers,' both of which will kickoff on June 13 with episodes featuring Christina Aguilera.
Other announced series include 'You're Cut Off,' featuring nine spoiled party girls in dire need of a reality check, 'Money Hungry,' a new take on the weight-loss competition genre in which contestants wager $10,000 of their own money, and 'Wedding Wars,' a competition-elimination series that pits eager engaged couples against one another for a dream wedding.
The network will also continue its 'Divas Live' concert series with 'VH1 and the USO Present Divas Rock The Troops,' airing in December, and is working with Queen Latifah's Flavor Unit Entertainment on a scripted film.
Noticeably absent from the lineup are signature reality shows like 'Rock of Love,' 'I Love New York,' 'Charm School' and 'Tool Academy.' "As much as they've enjoyed the 'Love' franchise, our audience was getting a little fatigued by all those manufactured reality shows," VH1 President Tom Calderone told the
Hollywood Reporter. "They want more authenticity in their reality, which isn't to say that it can't be comedic and light."
Indeed, after years of indulging in programming that critics often labeled tawdry or demeaning, VH1 was forced to confront the faults in its casting process -- and really, in the type and quality of the shows it was airing -- when, in August of 2009, Ryan Jenkins, a contestant on the then-airing 'Megan Wants a Millionaire,' who was also reportedly filming the third installment of the network's 'I Love Money' series, stood accused of murdering his ex-wife in California. A week later, Jenkins was found dead of an apparent suicide in a Canadian hotel. Both series were immediately canceled.
The
New York Times notes that many former VH1 executives have speculated that the "sleazy nature" of the 'Love' franchises may have turned off advertisers -- a charge the network has denied. VH1 insists the decision to revise its content was in the works long before the tragic events associated with Jenkins. "We'd already begun that process and we were already trying to reframe the lens and reset where the network was going and have a clear vision of where we wanted to go," says Olde. "So that architecture was in place quite a while back. We had a real determination last spring -- like, 'Ok, this is going great, now what's behind these stories. Let's start producing new kinds of storytelling for the network, and get our audience to start watching other kinds of shows.'"
The net is revising its "celebreality" formula, with new shows that are more purpose-driven -- like the Jessica Simpson vehicle 'The Price of Beauty.' "I want VH1 to feel like an interesting place for interesting talent to be," says Olde.
"Our doors are always open and we're always talking to celebrities, but I think they have to be interesting. You have to have a story that you want to tell," says Olde. "We're not interested in doing puff pieces. I love the message behind Jessica's show, I really do. I love that she has put herself out there in that way."
Advertisers once weary of having their products associated with VH1's content are already coming forward to admit they are relieved by the net's new direction. "A lot of their new stuff should be an easier fit," a national TV buyer, who once avoided VH1's programming, told
THR.
The only question remaining is one of viewer response. The first season finale of 'I Love New York' pulled in a whopping 4.8 million viewers (then a record for the network) and the first season of 'I Love Money' helped the network lead all cable channels in the 18-34 demographic during the summer of 2008. Will the same viewers who made these shows hits tune in en masse to a new, more-adult VH1?
http://xml.channel.aol.com/xmlpublisher/fetch.v2.xml?option=expand_relative_urls&dataUrlNodes=uiConfig,feedConfig,entry&id=691977&pid=691976&uts=1271966395
http://www.popeater.com/mm_track/popeater/music/?s_channel=us.musicpop&s_account=aolpopeater,aolsvc&omni=1&ke=1
http://cdn.channel.aol.com/cs_feed_v1_6/csfeedwrapper.swf
PopScene: Week's Hottest Pics
Vinny Guadagnino and Mike "The Situation" Sorrentino pick up food on what appears to be a warm night in Miami.
Bauer-Griffin
Bauer-Griffin
PopScene: Weeks Hottest Pics
Add a comment
I am a little beyond their demographic. Nonetheless, I do watch VH1 from time to time...but I tune it in for the music, not the asinine sleaze or reality shows. I am glad to hear about the return of Behind the Music and Storytellers. Hell, I'd rather see Pop Up Video than some of the "love" crap.
Reply
I really miss the ORIGINAL VH1. I was an original fan. When they quit with the videos, I quit the show. Obviously, I'm 21 yrs older than the oldest member of their 'target audience', but hey, the lack of a true rock video network left a big hole in programming in my opinion.
Reply
I agree with you. I enjoyed the original VH1. I cant stand to watch it now with all the trainwrecks on there. It's all trash. It sounds like the shows they have slated such as, "You're cut off" sounds just as bad.
Maybe if these so-called music station played music videos, they would have more viewers...
Reply
Umm...what's a music video...?
I am absolutely thrilled beyond words about the new direction VH1 is taking! I truly hope that other networks will follow suit and move on from the cheap, lame and downright disgusting reality shows that have been airing on every network.
I hope that VH1 enjoys success like they have never seen before for their smart, yet daring, leap in this direction.
Reply
I agree with you. It's all trash at the present.
I hope they keep Celebrity Rehab and Sober House!
Reply
I've always believed anything is possible with VH1.
Right now, I'm watching Brandy & Ray J: A Family
Business, so I can get a clue about when her next
CD is going to be made and available in stores.
Judging by the 3'rd episode, at least there are plans
for that to happen, and I can't wait to see the finished
Brandy project either in music video or disk form.
If it's not released this year, I hope Brandy & Ray J
will be picked up for a 2'nd season on VH1, anyway.
Reply
"authenticity in their reality": Brandy killed someone, why don't they talk about it?
Reply
Glad u guys are returning to the orginal VH1. i do like some of the shows that you guys are running know. Please keep sober house and celebrity rehab. I loved watching tool academy and all of the other down right stupid shows. hey it was all great laughs. we watched just to see how far some of those idiots would go. a good idea for a show is to tell just how all those crazy shows were produced and filmed. Bring all the cast of the shows back to tell their sides. that would be interesting. good luck VH1. ROCK
Reply
I'm glad VH1 is getting back into music oriented programming. I had stopped watching VH1 mostly because it had too many reality shows.
Reply
I am so happy VH1 actually wants to put better programs in their line up. I was truly offended by some of the Love franchise shows...
Reply
Its time for the regular stations, MTV, BET, TV One, and TV Land.
Reply
I applaud VH1's courage. Get back to the roots, music & music related programming. Celeb-resleeze can be left to the guyz.
Reply
Thank Goodness someones taking out the trash!!! TV has been rotten and stinking up peoples living rooms as well as their brains for quite some time. I find it DISTURBING to see whats on TV these days. Its downright sickening, and exploitative. Its the modern De-evolution of the average human being. Good riddance to bad garbage. now only if other networks would follow suit. someone needs to tell these celebrities and reality show freaks that intelligent people who matter dont give a damn about what happens in their pathetic lives.
Reply