On Monday morning, political rapper/singer M.I.A. released a controversial 9-minute short film for her latest single 'Born Free' depicting red headed teenagers being rounded up by U.S. authorities and forced to run through an active minefield. The video is brutal, uncompromising and merciless, but was it enough to get banned from YouTube?
In the video, a group of police officers, with conspicuous U.S. flags stitched into their uniform, break into various homes, beating up onlookers and interlopers while rounding up redheads to violently escort to a prison bus. After being driven to the desert in the middle of nowhere, the teenagers are forced at gunpoint to run through a minefield. With its graphic depictions of point-blank shootings and bodily explosions, it's a difficult, yet necessary, video to watch.
[The video] depicts the kind of things that most nations - including the U.S., which is portrayed as the aggressor in the clip - often pretend don't happen: the rounding-up of ethnic minorities, the trampling of personal liberties, the bullying of the powerless by those with authority. And it does so in an unflinchingly, unapologetically real way.
On her Twitter page, M.I.A. originally lashed out against her parent label, Universal Music Group (UMG), for allegedly banning the video, stating "F*CK UMG WHO WON'T SHOW IT ON YOUTUBE" before following up minutes later with "OK NOT UMG FAULT!"
Later that day, the singer linked to this screenshot, a standard disclaimer by YouTube for any videos with controversial or adult-themed content. YouTube issued the following statement to PopEater and other outlets: "Our policy is to age-restrict content that has been flagged by the community and identified by our policy enforcement team as content that, while not violating our Community Guidelines, is not suitable for users under age 18." Ostensibly a tool to limit viewing by underage viewers, the restriction is hardly a ban, as anyone with an Internet connection, hands and the ability to say they were born before 1992 can view the video.
Here's where it gets tricky. Several news outlets reported that the video had been banned and taken down by YouTube, presumably based on the video's content. Yet in a statement to PopEater, a spokesperson for YouTube denied the company ever banned the video and only took down links at the request of M.I.A.'s record label XL Recordings. A quick search of the video as of Tuesday yielded at least one unavailable link with the message: "This video is no longer available due to a copyright claim by XL Recordings."
M.I.A. and director Romain Gavras declined to comment for this story. A message seeking comment from XL Recordings was not returned.
Both M.I.A. and the video's director, Romain Gavras, are no strangers to controversy. The daughter of a Sri Lankan Tamil activist, M.I.A. has been a frequent and outspoken critic of the Sri Lankan government and their alleged abuses and atrocities against the Tamil people. Gavras is the son of Costa Gavras, the Greek-French director best known for 1969's politically-charged 'Z,' and has earned a name for his tense, guerrilla-style videos.
The singer took over Pitchfork's twitter feed yesterday, regaling the online music site's readers with a series of lines including "go egosurfing DRINK A SHOT OF TEQUILLA spamouflaged in brandalism" and "i got digital cash Hactivism at its best Google Bombing with my Infotainment." The video can also be seen on M.I.A.'s website.
M.I.A. - 'Born Free' (WARNING: EXTREMELY VIOLENT WITH NUDITY)
Singer M.I.A. arrives at the Jimmy Choo for H&M Collection private event in support of the Motion Picture & Television Fund on November 2, 2009 in West Hollywood, California. More M.I.A. photos >>
Getty Images
Getty Images North America
M.I.A. Snapshots
LOS ANGELES, CA - NOVEMBER 02: Jimmy Choo founder Tamara Mellon and singer M.I.A. arrive at the Jimmy Choo for H&M Collection private event in support of the Motion Picture & Television Fund on November 2, 2009 in West Hollywood, California.. (Photo by Alberto E. Rodriguez/Getty Images) *** Local Caption *** Tamara Mellon;M.I.A.
LOS ANGELES, CA - NOVEMBER 02: Singer M.I.A. arrives at the Jimmy Choo for H&M Collection private event in support of the Motion Picture & Television Fund on November 2, 2009 in West Hollywood, California.. (Photo by Alberto E. Rodriguez/Getty Images) *** Local Caption *** M.I.A.
LOS ANGELES, CA - NOVEMBER 02: Jimmy Choo founder Tamara Mellon and singer M.I.A. arrive at the Jimmy Choo for H&M Collection private event in support of the Motion Picture & Television Fund on November 2, 2009 in West Hollywood, California.. (Photo by Alberto E. Rodriguez/Getty Images) *** Local Caption *** Tamara Mellon;M.I.A.
LOS ANGELES, CA - NOVEMBER 02: Singer M.I.A. arrives at the Jimmy Choo for H&M Collection private event in support of the Motion Picture & Television Fund on November 2, 2009 in West Hollywood, California.. (Photo by Alberto E. Rodriguez/Getty Images) *** Local Caption *** M.I.A.
LOS ANGELES, CA - NOVEMBER 02: Singer M.I.A. arrives at the Jimmy Choo for H&M Collection private event in support of the Motion Picture & Television Fund on November 2, 2009 in West Hollywood, California.. (Photo by Alberto E. Rodriguez/Getty Images) *** Local Caption *** M.I.A.
LOS ANGELES, CA - NOVEMBER 02: Singer M.I.A. arrives at the Jimmy Choo for H&M Collection private event in support of the Motion Picture & Television Fund on November 2, 2009 in West Hollywood, California.. (Photo by Alberto E. Rodriguez/Getty Images) *** Local Caption *** M.I.A.
Singer M.I.A. arrives at the Jimmy Choo for H&M Collection private event in support of the Motion Picture & Television Fund on November 2, 2009 in West Hollywood, California. Jimmy Choo For H&M Collection Exclusive Launch Party Hollywood, CA United States November 2, 2009 Photo by Jon Kopaloff/FilmMagic.com To license this image (17024532), contact FilmMagic.com
Singer M.I.A. arrives at the Jimmy Choo for H&M Collection private event in support of the Motion Picture & Television Fund on November 2, 2009 in West Hollywood, California. Jimmy Choo For H&M Collection Exclusive Launch Party Hollywood, CA United States November 2, 2009 Photo by Jon Kopaloff/FilmMagic.com To license this image (17024529), contact FilmMagic.com
Singer M.I.A. (Wearing Jimmy Choo) performs at the Jimmy Choo for H&M Collection private event in support of the Motion Picture & Television Fund on November 2, 2009 in West Hollywood, California. Jimmy Choo For H&M Collection - Show West Hollywood, CA United States November 2, 2009 Photo by Michael Caulfield/WireImage.com To license this image (58808987), contact WireImage.com
M.I.A. arrives at Jimmy Choo For H&M at a private residence on November 2, 2009 in West Hollywood, California. Jimmy Choo For H&M - Arrivals West Hollywood, CA United States November 2, 2009 Photo by Jordan Strauss/WireImage.com To license this image (58809470), contact WireImage.com
have you ever heard of Andamana Islands? it is an island administered by india and located in Indian ocean. among the tribes that live in that island,there were people that had african hair texture. in 1976 when I was a student in India, I heard that there were people in that island who looked liked me,and that they were subjected to systematic extermination. I expressed my interest in visiting the island but sadly the place was off limits to foreigners, let alone the rest of indians. the last member of those minority inhabitants of that place died some time this year. her death caused an extinction of never to be retrieved. languege, culture and civilizarion. we haven't heard an uproar from the so called enviromentalists and humanitarians.extermination of voiceless still goes on. would someone tell me why we do not hear any thing about the uprooted people of the diago garcia island which was administered by the great britain and was leased to U.S.A. more power to those who expose evil in the name of more money.
I have seen worse in a cheap B movie. I am sick of so called "artists" who think we give a crap about their opinions. To all the Bono's and Sean Penn's out there, shut up and enjoy your millions, your 15 minutes is over.
Kick butt track and awesome video. Just because the peanut gallery here doesnt apprecitate integrity or creativity doesnt mean it's not important. It is.
And to the bozo who referred to Bono and Penn's 15 minutes. well their 15 minutess has lasted almost thirty years and is still going by everyones count. You havent even had that. so go back to yanking it in the stock room at home depot.
Uh...where's the song? Alot of nice,put together images with a heavy beat in the background,but that's all it appears to be,if all the scratchy yelling over the synth effects are supposed to be "the song" then were in trouble here.Where's the song?
If she & her friend are concerned w/ how this people are treated in these countries, why don't she go down thier & say something to those government officials. instead of getting others to fight the cause she thinks need fighting. sorry the only war i want our sons,brothers,fathers,mothers,uncles,aunts. are the wars that will interfere with thier way of life not some Else's.if some off you don't feel that way,you know where to go to do something about it.
ok fine by me. AOL is hangin on by a thread. And all I have to do is take em out of my favs. No skin off my nose. They will notice me gone. Know why? Because nobody is signing with AOL. Everybody is dumpin em. You just added to it. And I'll be sure to tell em why I'm dumpin em Mr Newman.
iliked how MIA used gingers because its a group of people that we see every day so the video hits close to home and the fact is this happens everyday all over the globe
This is absolute junk-like a high school filmmaking project. It purports to be shocking but I was cracking up most of the time. Laughable-an al-Queda freakout or two may be turned on, nobody else.
What people think is 'music' and how 'artist' is defined nowadays is indicative of the crap thats on the radio and on tv. This is not music. The video is dumb. At least the concept is interesting. Too many sheep.
I like the idea of the video but I can see why its not on youtube... I dont think i'd want my little brother or sister watching this. The message of this video is very serious and I wouldnt want the young generation thinking this is funny... as one response said.
What a silly mommy! Katie Holmes takes Suri into the water in her clothes as the two spend the afternoon at the beach in Miami. More of Today's Hottest Photos
Add a comment
have you ever heard of Andamana Islands? it is an island administered by india and located in Indian ocean. among the tribes that live in that island,there were people that had african hair texture. in 1976 when I was a student in India, I heard that there were people in that island who looked liked me,and that they were subjected to systematic extermination. I expressed my interest in visiting the island but sadly the place was off limits to foreigners, let alone the rest of indians. the last member of those minority inhabitants of that place died some time this year. her death caused an extinction of never to be retrieved. languege, culture and civilizarion. we haven't heard an uproar from the so called enviromentalists and humanitarians.extermination of voiceless still goes on. would someone tell me why we do not hear any thing about the uprooted people of the diago garcia island which was administered by the great britain and was leased to U.S.A. more power to those who expose evil in the name of more money.
Reply
I have seen worse in a cheap B movie. I am sick of so called "artists" who think we give a crap about their opinions. To all the Bono's and Sean Penn's out there, shut up and enjoy your millions, your 15 minutes is over.
Great video....too bad about the song.
Reply
Kick butt track and awesome video. Just because the peanut gallery here doesnt apprecitate integrity or creativity doesnt mean it's not important. It is.
And to the bozo who referred to Bono and Penn's 15 minutes. well their 15 minutess has lasted almost thirty years and is still going by everyones count. You havent even had that. so go back to yanking it in the stock room at home depot.
Reply
It wouldn't be the first time when prophets were burned for delivering un conventional message. history will always repeat itself.
I think it's racism...somehow...right. White bad ... dark good.
Reply
Uh...where's the song? Alot of nice,put together images with a heavy beat in the background,but that's all it appears to be,if all the scratchy yelling over the synth effects are supposed to be "the song" then were in trouble here.Where's the song?
Reply
forget about the blame game. that is a form of escapesim. get to know somebody and you might be relatives. they might have your dna
Reply
If she & her friend are concerned w/ how this people are treated in these countries, why don't she go down thier & say something to those government officials. instead of getting others to fight the cause she thinks need fighting. sorry the only war i want our sons,brothers,fathers,mothers,uncles,aunts. are the wars that will interfere with thier way of life not some Else's.if some off you don't feel that way,you know where to go to do something about it.
Reply
ok fine by me. AOL is hangin on by a thread. And all I have to do is take em out of my favs. No skin off my nose. They will notice me gone. Know why? Because nobody is signing with AOL. Everybody is dumpin em. You just added to it. And I'll be sure to tell em why I'm dumpin em Mr Newman.
Reply
iliked how MIA used gingers because its a group of people that we see every day so the video hits close to home and the fact is this happens everyday all over the globe
Reply
This is absolute junk-like a high school filmmaking project. It purports to be shocking but I was cracking up most of the time.
Laughable-an al-Queda freakout or two may be turned on, nobody else.
Reply
What people think is 'music' and how 'artist' is defined nowadays is indicative of the crap thats on the radio and on tv. This is not music. The video is dumb. At least the concept is interesting. Too many sheep.
Reply
I like the idea of the video but I can see why its not on youtube... I dont think i'd want my little brother or sister watching this. The message of this video is very serious and I wouldnt want the young generation thinking this is funny... as one response said.
Reply