Celebrities Don't Really Die in Threes ... Do They?

There's an old saying that celebrity deaths always come in threes (old, that is, if you're the kind of person who frequently reads or writes about celebrity mortality).
Sometimes it just seems to ring true. Back in June 2009, there was the funereal trio of Michael Jackson, Farrah Fawcett and Ed McMahon. When actress Brittany Murphy passed away in December of last year, followed swiftly by socialite Casey Johnson, the very morbid among us were trying to place a third. Some tabloids argued that though it happened several months later, Corey Haim's death by overdose fulfilled that triumvirate.
Going back another year -- to January 2008 -- Brad Renfro, Heath Ledger and Suzanne Pleshette all died within a week of each other.
This week, people are again talking about the "rule of three" in relation to the deaths of Dennis Hopper, Gary Coleman and and Rue McClanahan.
The rule of three can be traced back to Feb. 3, 1959, when Buddy Holly, Richie Valens and the Big Bopper all died in a plane crash in an Iowa cornfield. The theory gained a place in creepy celebrity lore at the end of 1970 and the beginning of 1971, when iconic rockers Janis Joplin, Jimi Hendrix and Jim Morrison died in relatively close succession. That one really rattled people, as all three died at age 27.
Since then, the so-called rule of three has provided a tidy way for folks to try to make sense of celebrity deaths.
So, is the universe trying to tell us something when three people a lot of people happen to be familiar with pass away in close proximity to one another? Or, as human beings, do we try to rationalize the horror of death by imposing some kind of order on random tragedy?
"The concept of things happening in threes is deeply rooted in religious beliefs like Christianity, the Holy Trinity, the Three Wise Men, etc.," explains 'Cult of Celebrity' author Cooper Lawrence. "But the notion that bad things happen in threes is mostly superstition. Two deaths may happen and we add a random, close enough third to it. Or there are four, but we dismiss the third to keep to our 'deaths happen in threes' rule. The reason we do it is that once we have found the third we no longer have to wonder if it will be us. Finding a pattern to death helps us master our own mortality."
http://xml.channel.aol.com/xmlpublisher/fetch.v2.xml?option=expand_relative_urls&dataUrlNodes=uiConfig,feedConfig,entry&id=822797&pid=822796&uts=1275423796
http://www.popeater.com/mm_track/popeater/music/?s_channel=us.musicpop&s_account=aolpopeater,aolsvc&omni=1&ke=1
http://cdn.channel.aol.com/cs_feed_v1_6/csfeedwrapper.swf
Recently Departed Celebrities
Dennis Hopper, May 29: The Hollywood wild man who lit up the screen in classic films 'Easy Rider,' Blue Velvet' and 'True Romance, died at his home in Venice less than a year after being diagnosed with prostate cancer. He was 74.
Getty Images
Getty Images
Bonnie Fuller, editor-in-chief of
HollywoodLife.com, has a keen eye for celebrity trends, and she also debunks the myth of deaths happening in threes, but believes that the myth holds true for other celebrity occurrences -- like pregnancies and marriages.
"I do think it is people trying to make a pattern out of terrible events, and there can't really be a connection between people who have no relationship passing away," Fuller explains. "But there are occurrences that do become like these viral events, like celebrity marriages and vow renewals, engagements and pregnancies. But that is more about folks being inspired by someone and the idea catching on in Hollywood."
It's interesting that in numerology the number 3 represents the number of communication, because a trio of famous people passing away really does seem to stir up a lot of conversation. But despite the number being significant in numerology, celebrity numerologist
Glynis McCants says that deaths happening in three is indeed an old wives' tale.
"It's just never true that they die in threes. There are always more or less, but people try to fit it into a three," McCants explains. "But because three is the number of communication, it gets people talking and by talking people feel like they are able to control death. We like to believe, if it is three, we can handle it. It makes people feel safe, but unfortunately the rule just isn't true."
Watch the Girls on Pop: Do Celebrity Deaths Come in Threes?
Add a comment
There is no logic to death.The only thing that we know for sure about it's appearance is that each one of us will be it's victim.
Reply
Oh, please. Eventually, yes, three celebrities will die. Is there a time limit? What if there are four in a month--then you start over? This is silly. Humans love to look for patterns, so they often create them when there's nothing really there. As someone pointed out, you had Art Linkletter, Gary Coleman and Dennis Hopper all in the last few days. So, is Rue McClanahan now the start of a new 3-celebrity pattern?
It's silly.
Reply
Corey Haim died of pneumonia, not an overdose.
Reply
people die by the hundreds every day. When are we supposed to start the "3" count? Just because you know someone's name? This is all hooey. You people must also believe in fortune tellers!
Reply
IT'S NOT 3, IT'S 4 YOU PELICAN. YOU LEFT OUT ART LINKLETTER!
Reply
They are all just old has-beens. Nothing special about any of them. What is the big deal?
Reply
I say rip to all no one death is greater or less then the other one lets just miss them all an enjoy the memory they left behind.
Reply
People die. Its something we all are going to face one day. I dont think there is such a thing as dying in 3s. Why waste your life trying to figure out why they died the same time as other people. Im sure around the world millions of people died the same day as these people. And one more thing. The only true celebs are Hopper & Rue. Coleman wasted his life being a criminal and acting crazy. I do believe in honoring the dead and respecting them. But I also believe you had to do some good in your life to deserve that honor.
Reply
Add the Boston Celtics to that death list !! LOL
Reply
My guess at least 3 actors die every month. Just a hunch.
Reply
Your three are actually Art Linkletter, Gary Coleman and Dennis Hopper. Rue will be the start of three female celebrities. I can't believe you left out Art.
Reply
There are actually a lot more than 3 at a time if people would give due respect to all who contributed to the industry. When Gale Storm died, you hardly heard a word about it because of Michael Jackson. Once you are a "has been", it's like you're a "never was". Even Farrah Fawcett's death was pushed aside after Jackson's death. It seems the media decides who deserves more recognition rather than based on merit.
Reply
Who cares about these people? They are no different then the rest of us except they usually have screwed up lives from the years of people treating them like they are special. I get so tired of listening to people talk about when "famous" people die. Who we should be talking about are the heros that protect this country, past and current. Do you know how many WWII WARRIORS we loose EVERYDAY!!!!!!!!!! Now those are people worthy of talking about. GOD BLESS AMERICA EVEN THOUGH THIS COUNTRY AND IT'S LEADERS HAVE FORGOTTEN HIM!
Reply
Farrah Fawcett, Ed McMahon, Michael Jackson and it just isn't with celebrities.
Reply
way way back( late 80's ?) lucille ball , laurence olivier , and mel blanc
Reply
Gary Coleman, Dennis Hopper, Art Linkletter. That was the three. Rue McClanahan is the first of the next three. Was that so hard to figure out?
Reply
dio and gray I would group with Elisha Cuthbert, who died may 10th
Reply
I can't believe NO ONE has mentioned Cary Grant. He was one of the all time greatest actors.
Reply
You are wrong that the belief that celebrities dies in 3 dates back only to the 70's. I am in my 60's. As a child in the 50's I recall my mother saying that "people usually die in 3's". This saying/belief does not only refer to celebrities but to ALL people and incidents of misfortune.
Reply
You are basing this on the idea that this "celebrities die in threes" thing is a fact. It's not. You're forcing things into a pattern that doesn't exist. Rue McClanahan doesn't fit into your pattern, so you say she starts the next one. How silly. BTW, is there a time limit within which the next two have to die?
Reply