Readers Speak: Our Relationship Was As Bad As Mel and Oksana's, And We Turned It Around
Beyond the issues of alleged abuse and racism, of audio rants possibly tampered with, of restraining orders and child custody, one thing was clear from Mel Gibson's first tape-recorded F-bomb: His relationship with Oksana Grigorieva had become a poisoned union, beyond salvaging, without a shadow of a doubt ... right?
Not so, say PopEater readers. Several chimed in to announce that they, too, were in disastrous relationships like Mel and Oksana's -- cursing, threats, abysmally lacking communication -- and managed to turn things around. Read three accounts of hope not lost.
Nicholas James: 'Therapy Turned My Rancid Relationship Around'
My girlfriend, Nina, was everything I'd ever wanted: Beautiful, passionate and someone I wanted to share my life with. But after a year, our relationship turned sour. Nina was up for a promotion at work and I supported her to the fullest. She came home with fire in her eyes -- her boss had decided to promote another employee at the bank. Despite what I said to comfort Nina,
she pushed me away and called me every name in the book. "What do you know, you stupid nobody!" she screamed. I calmly told her she'd get the next job. She slammed the bedroom door in my face. That night I slept on the couch; I can still feel the aching pain when I think about it. My feelings -- my
heart -- were crushed.
A couple days later, Nina was mad again, this time because of the way a customer at the bank had treated her. "If you made more money, I wouldn't have to work!" she snapped. This time, I wasn't going to be her punching bag, and I defended myself. "Nina, I know you're upset, but don't blame me for how a customer treats you," I said. "I'm here for you, but right now you're taking everything out on me, and it hurts." Nina and I began barely speaking, and I have to admit, it was a relief not to be yelled at by the person I loved.
Before long, Nina was screaming at me for everything that went wrong. She was mad at me if her tire went flat, her alarm didn't go off in the morning, or if she was stuck in traffic. I asked her to try talking to a therapist. After some convincing, we made an appointment with a respected professional. The woman was kind, patient, and seemed to care about helping. Nina and I began talking out our problems, and I expressed how much Nina's cruel words hurt me. Within a month, our relationship was stronger than ever. Instead of blaming others for her problems, Nina learned how to express frustrations in a positive way. Exercise allowed her to relax and ease her mind after a long day at the bank. Two years later our love had grown. At first, Nina's outbursts resembled Mel Gibson's mean-spirited rants, but
with love, patience, and understanding, we found a way to be happy and work out our problems. After all, if it's meant to be, it's worth the fight.
Kitty Cruiser: 'Sometimes It's Worth Holding On'
My husband was my high school sweetheart, but a few years back, he started seeing a girl he worked with. She was seven years his junior and he seemed proud of the fact. For three and a half years he saw her on and off, behind -- and sometimes not so behind -- my back. He pushed for divorce, but I tried my best to stay strong and not give in to that nonsense. He would tell me how much he loved this other girl and how he never loved me.
The more he pushed away from me, the harder I held on. He tried to push me over the edge by putting me down left and right. My husband -- the man who promised to love, honor and cherish me -- made fun of my height, my weight and my overall appearance. His words came close to echoing some of what Mel said to Oksana; his words cut me deeper than any knife could. Every time I looked at him, I wondered what happened to the man who once declared his love for me on a daily basis. At times, giving in to the divorce seemed like the most logical and healthy thing for me to do. But I couldn't. I held on even though I felt like I was dying inside.
I finally broke one night and asked him if he still had feelings for the other woman. He said he was confused and did not know. I demanded he figure out his feelings and -- if the outcome were not in our favor -- I would agree to a divorce. A few days after that last confrontation, my husband had come to realize that what he felt for the other woman was not love. He had gotten it in his head that it was easier to run away with this object of infatuation than to fix the problems in our marriage. He knew that he did not want to spend the rest of his life with this other woman. Since his epiphany, our marriage has been better than it was in years. I don't know what the future holds for us, but if we can overcome that ordeal, maybe we can overcome any other obstacle that gets in our way.
Ryan Phillips: 'I Was Like Mel'
Mr. Gibson, I have been there. My fiance of two years and I were having serious problems for a while. I have to admit, most of the issues came from an anger problem I never knew I had.
I never hit her, but I would hit everything and everyone around us. I had to replace a whole sheet of drywall in my bedroom one weekend, because it rained and I wanted sunshine. Looking back on it, I feel like a total idiot. She finally left me and I realized I needed to change.
She and I agreed it would be best to start our relationship over from scratch. I know this is easier said than done but it is possible -- we're proof. We pretended that we never met each other. We started talking, then dating, then more and more. Finally we were back where we wanted to be. All we had to do was keep the right mindset; throughout all the pretending,
we learned to listen to each other more, and learned quite a bit about our emotions. When I started to get angry, she would tell me how she felt, which reminded me of all the tragic mistakes I made in the past.
After a while I knew how she felt before I made any physical action. Now we tell each other how we feel in a calm and peaceful manner. It
does become a challenge at times, but seeing her reminds me of what really matters to me; keeping her and loving each other. We have never been more in love than we are right now. Every relationship has problems and finding a way to deal with them is the easy part. Doing the actual work is the hard part that's so very worth it.
http://xml.channel.aol.com/xmlpublisher/fetch.v2.xml?option=expand_relative_urls&dataUrlNodes=uiConfig,feedConfig,entry&id=762708&pid=762707&uts=1273853626
http://www.popeater.com/mm_track/popeater/movies/?s_channel=us.moviespop&s_account=aolpopeater,aolsvc&omni=1&ke=1
http://cdn.channel.aol.com/cs_feed_v1_6/csfeedwrapper.swf
Celebrity Splitsville
Halle Berry and Gabriel Aubry
Split
Halle Berry called it quits with her boyfriend, Gabriel Aubry, ending their five-year relationship. The couple has a 2-year-old daughter, Nahla Ariel Aubry.
Evan Agostini, AP
Evan Agostini, AP
Celebrity Splits
Add a comment
I think once you sell doctored tapes to the press to destroy a mans life in the media there is no turning it around.But i think Mel may have a shot with his ex-wife.
Reply
We don't know that any tapes were doctored. Mel gone through a difficult mid-life crisis, hence the marriage to a girl who looks young enough to be his daughter. He has however brought a child into the world and he certainly has responsibilities to her. If he abused his young wife he should go to jail.
If I were his ex I wouldn't take him back. She is not his mother.
What a mess Mel. Get the help you need and try to act like an adult for the rest of your life please.
We've all heard (by now) what Mel is really all about. He's an abuser, plain and simple. I don't think he deserves another woman EVER, nor his career back. If you look up the definition of sociopath, Mel fits the description perfectly. He obviously has Narcissistic Personality Disorder as well as Antisocial Personality Disorder, and in fact, could be the 'poster child' for both of those mental defects. He's far beyond having 'anger issues'. Old Yeller got 'mad' too, and see what happened to him?
Please do NOT confuse your relationships with her planned money extortion from ever drunk Mel. She was in Fance and Spain with him in February though she was "terribly bitten". He refused to marry her, she lost her access to his money, that's was the point!! She flew to Moscow in April where she got her edited tapes done. They erased her provocative voice and recorded her "meak and quiet" voice. She got all instructions how to act there. Poor guy..
Reply
My husband and I have had alot of problems, we have both been equally mean to each other at times and said things we shouldnt have. I have been deeply depressed for years due to very sad things that have happened in our lives and I think I have blamed him for everything..we have thought about divorce and but we both do love each other very much,,,I think we both need couseling...Love is all that matters and keeping our family together..
Reply
If you're sick enough to let a man hit you and keep him around, you need to pick out a grave stone, because any person who would do that or verbally abuse you doesn't care. Actions speak louder than words - so do bruises and broken teeth.
Reply
Good post and great point Erin. You're absolutely right!
That is easier said than done and until you have been in that situation, you have no right to judge. Yes, what you may be saying is they truth, but until you know what it is like to truly love someone and be utterly baffled by the way they treat you when they are "angry" or lose their temper, you have no ground to stand on. It is easier to SAY that you will leave a relationship than to actually do it.
I was once involved with a man who promised me the world then pulled a "Mel" on me...then I promptly let him know that it was over. I thought we were working on our issues and would eventually work things out between us...until one day he texted me he was engaged to a wonderful Russian lady...totally out of the blue. I think he probably got exactly what he deserved. Btw, I'm okay...I've happily moved on with all my teeth and dignity intact.
Reply
This is the stupidest article. You don't even know these people, and you definitely don't know their relationship so why would you write an article "Our Relationship Was As Bad As Mel and Oksana's"
Reply
O for God's sake, Nick, Kitty, and Ryan - I don't care about your loser relationships any more than I care about Mel Gibson's. Do thak you for the laugh and hope you manage to get on Dr. Phil.
Reply
It's no one's business but Mel's and Oskana's,give them a break and leave them alone. She is old enough to know what to do.... so butt out.All the do-gooders in the world should look in their own back yard...I'm sure they will find something to talk about.
Mel is a great actor and thats all I need to know....so get on with your lives because no one really cares what you think about them.
Reply
I COULDN'T AGREE WITH YOU MORE, ROXIE
That's right you tell them.
My question is, who know if this women is telling the truth. I am not being mean, but I have experience with these Russian women like this women. My best friend got involved with one, just like this women, and she destroyed his life, with lies, made up stuff trying to exhort money from him, even getting him arrested for supposedly hitting her, and my friend is the gentlest human being on the planet. I have known him for 30 years and he does not have a mean bone in this body. The whole business was trying to get his home, cars, and a whole settlement out of him. He was also her 3 American husband since she came into this country, and she cleaned all 3.
Reply
I was married to a man that had an anger problem and after he hit me once; I told him if it ever happened again, we were finished.
Thank goodness, we had no children.
And, of course it happened again, since he refused to get help.
So, here I am, Happy and Content and bruiseless.
Reply
If someone were treated THAT badly, why would anyone possibly want to salvage that (kind of) relationship?! That's just plain madness. If they will treat you anything like that, they certainly DO NOT love you! Get the heck away from them.
Reply
IMO, I think Mel deserves a little jail time where he can learn what it is like to be the 'oppressed girlfriend'.
Reply
Love shouldn't hurt.
Reply