That was only on the gay charts. Clay could sing. but Fantasia has a gift.I will pray for her. all things are possible through him. And if those without sins was going to line up to throw stones. There would be a line of 1. Stay strong. Take care of yourself and your instrument. you will always be in demand. i don't get to see you nearly enough.

Clay did not "win"... he was second. The article was refering to "winners". She is a "winner"... not number 2!!!! I do like Clay as well... I love his "spirit".

Who cares about Clay Gayken!

Betsy, I have just one thing to say to your post...Do no judge lest ye be judged!

Judge not lest you be judged. We see What Fantasia did, God Knows why she did it. Yes the actions look bad but God and God only know what truely happened, her motives and this married mans motives. Only God knows the heart people just see the actions!

Keep you panties up dear. Never go with a man that is still married. You are still you, you still have a lot to learn. And never ever film. Still shots or moving ones.

A little judgemental aren't you??? She made mistakes in her life we all do. Why take it so personal. No one is perfect.

everyone makes mistakes dont judge her you dont even know what she is going through shake my head...like wtf

It was highly likely that the guy went after Fantasia, rather than her after him. He knew he was married before Fantasia knew it. He knew he had a family. Don't always lay the blame on the woman. I found in my 68 years there are some men, even ministers, who will go after other women, family or not. Give this women a break. Lift her up, don't tear her down any more than she's probably already has out-done you on that score.

BESTY ROSS, you and I both know that men LIE LIKE H-E hockey sticks. You don't know what he said to her, get real and think. I'm sure you have been lied to before. I am tired of people like you who thinks it's always the other persons fault, may it be man or woman. as for the wife she should not have said or done any thing to Tasia, her husband was the one who stepped out on the marriage. As the sayoing goes what you won't do someone else will. Tasia we love you. @ Mary, very well said.

I heard about it before it came out also but this man wasn't with his wife at the time. He went back to his wife. Were all on her but nobody has said anything about the man. Yes what she did wasn't right but you are not God and I'm pretty sure that you have done somethings in your life that you know wasn't rigt so to her, keep your head up, confess your sins to god, ask for forgiveness and move on.....Oh yeah didn't your mom and grandmother teach you about judging people. It's not your job...Sorry but it's the truth.

Don't be so quick to judge. How do u know he wasn't leaving the women anyway. The wife may just want headlines. 15mins of fame.

She did not know that she was sleeping with a married man. I saw the news today and it said that she was embaressed and sorry for the family she hurt.

I agree 100% with you...I hope the NC law gets her every state need that law...she should pay for your mistakes, take it like a women...mrs cook is...you had enough sense to tell her she's not women enough how about you...weak...after you got caught..A happyly married women

Shame on you. Dont you know better!!!!What were YOU taught? How could you kick a person when their down! Shame on you and all the naysayers.No one is perfect she just won a talent show.

Go after a man with a family?? Most men today over age 25 have a family and these men are not married. So... what the heck does that have to do with anything... The issue is that she dated someone who was married wether he had a family or not... he was married and apparently still hanging with his wife... He probably told Fantasca that they were separated like most men that want another woman will say... he is the "big" problem here.. And his wife might have been involved as well... Fantasca will learn from this and move on to a better man that can truly love her without baggage and he'll to honorable... This "tape thing" was probably his idea... to set her up along with that wife of his... I pray the court system will see thru. this foolishness... Anyway...women should stop blaming the other woman... blame your husband or man and blame yourself for hanging or being married to such a "fool". As the wife is stupid as well. Hang in there Fantasca you'll be OK... now that other woman and her husband will forever have issues. That "hunk" of a man she has will be forever playing the field with other woman. So "grow up" Mrs. Cook and "let this mess go"!!!!!!!

Well Besty Im sure ur closet is not clean as is all the others with their remarks. Have u been or r u married? do u know whether or not ur spouse have cheated on u or have u cheated? chances r the answer is "YES" but does it make it right? The Bible states None Are Perfect and if u haven't noticed that includes U!

Phyllis, at what point do you think she knew he was married? How about the beginning. And do you truly believe that she did not know about the tape? You are sadly fooling yourself if you don't think she knew everything all along. All of you are right, the Lord does tell us not to judge, that is his and his alone to do, but many times in the his Word he tells us to have good judgement and to be a great witness for him. From her life even before Idol it looks like she had walked away from God's teachings. I will not judge her for that because it is not my right to do that, but I will say she makes a very poor witness for Christ. Anyone can say they have Christ in their heart but their actions and how they live their lives tell the truth about if they live a lie. I will pray that one day she finds Christ and takes him for real as her savior. Only time will tell.