'Love and Other Drugs' star Jake Gyllenhaal has been ducking questions about his latest off-screen romance, but there was no avoiding the eagle eyes when he ducked into a local coffee shop in New York City with 20-year-old country singer Taylor Swift to pick up some tasty treats on Thanksgiving morning.

The pair were sighted Thursday at a trendy java vendor in Brooklyn's Park Slope neighborhood, according to People.com, where they ordered lattes made with real maple syrup. The lively establishment is reportedly frequented by Jake's big sis Maggie, who lives nearby with husband Peter Sarsgaard and their 4-year-old daughter.

"They get treated like normal people around here," says a source about the 29-year-old actor and his close-knit family.