For his latest transformation, Sanjaya Malakar has lost the faux-hawk and wacky outfits of his 'American Idol' days and turned to the NYC stage. The singer-actor is a new star of 'Freckleface Strawberry,' an Off-Broadway musical based on a book by actress Julianne Moore. But while in real life, Sanjaya still exudes that sugar-sweet personality that charmed TV viewers in 2007, in 'Freckleface' he's playing a "7-year-old jock."

"Yeah, it kinda fit!" he told me. "The character is kinda like the school jock heartthrob."