Fan Favorite Eliminated in 'American Idol' Shocker: Episode Recap

By AOL TV Editors Posted Apr 29th 2011 02:00AM

Ryan Seacrest warned us early on in tonight's Top 6 elimination show that many fans would be disappointed with the results. Right then and there it became somewhat obvious who was going home. But first, let's touch on the night's happenings.

The Idols paid a visit to the British Consulate because, well, there's that whole wedding thing going on and Rob Reiner wasn't available. But Fred Willard was!

Casey Abrams and Fred shared a moment where I'm convinced neither knew who the other was. The wheel of random celebrity Idol run-ins keeps on spinning; where it lands nobody knows!

Back to the live show, the kids took to the stage for a clunky medley of Carole King hits, featuring Scotty surrounded by a group of unenthusiastic teen girls. The whole thing felt very stiff and antiquated. But boy, does Scotty sound good when he's not twanged out on some country song.

Tonight's Ford music video kept up the hallucinogenic theme of recent weeks, with the kids in a white room, drawing furniture while singing 'Our House.' Then everyone's eyes turned to saucers and the walls started melting ...

Speaking of hallucinogenics, Crystal Bowersox and her bong mic stand returned to the 'Idol' stage, with organ, harmonica and lap steel accompaniment, on her new single, 'Ridin' With the Radio.' Crystal sounded -- and looked -- amazing, which is all she'll have to go on since Ryan didn't give her a chance to plug anything.

Next up, a little question and answer sesh, brought to you by AT&T. Ryan fired off some viewer queries at the Top 6. We learned that given the chance to perform with one artist, living or dead, Casey Abrams would chose Jazz pianist Oscar Peterson. No one knew who he was talking about except for two people in the audience and Randy, who made sure we knew he knew. Also, Lauren gave a shout-out to those in the Southeast affected by the tornadoes, and Scotty revealed that he used to work at a grocery store. Really wish Rob Reiner was back ...

Finally, Ryan started to get down to the results, explaining that he'd be calling the Idols up in random order. But first, that font of musical wisdom and sassy soundbites, Jimmy Iovine, commented on each of the contestants' strengths and weaknesses in a pre-tape.

Haley came forward first and Jimmy expressed concern over her lack of self-awareness. Who is Haley? This has to be one of the most annoying and persistent complaints the contestants get, year after year. Haley shrugged it off and Randy mouthed "I know who you are" from the judges' panel. Not to worry, tonight, however. Haley was safe, whoever she is.

Scotty stepped up next. Jimmy compared him to Johnny Cash, in a roundabout way, and was worried that Scotty's "magnificent subtlety" might be lost on viewers. Ryan made him sweat it out and called Lauren up. Jimmy fretted that she's too concerned with negative comments. Lauren promised to put it aside and just be grateful she's still in the competition. But there was no immediate relief for her either, as Ryan sent Lauren off with Scotty.

Jimmy was on point with much of his commentary tonight, but when it came to Casey Abrams, he nailed it. He pointed out Casey's great musicianship, but asked that he stop the growling, as "the family dog does not vote on the show." Rawr!

James Durbin followed Casey, still unaware of his fate. Jimmy pointed out that James was more believable when he sings a melody with a rock feel than when he tries to go metal, a spot-on observation. There was no point in dangling James' fate in front of him, especially after last night's great performance of The Shirelles' 'Will You Love Me Tomorrow?' James promptly took a seat next to Haley.

Bottom three vet, Jacob Lusk followed James. The warring patterns in Jacob's attire last night were more fitting for 'Dancing With the Stars,' according to Jimmy. He put the gospel singer on "banana peel" status, which isn't surprising, considering he's hanging by a thread, albeit, a very colorful one.

Before Bruno Mars took to the stage to perform, 'The Lazy Song,' complete with a brass band lounging on a couch while playing, Lauren was let off the hook. Scotty, Casey and Jacob, though not necessarily the bottom three as the order was random tonight, were the last to know.

Scotty was swiftly sent back to safety with Casey and Jacob remaining. Surely, Jacob would be the one sent packing, but it was Casey who took the fall. Choosing to reprise 'I Put a Spell on You,' Casey let loose (perhaps what J.Lo was talking about last night), walking into the audience and up to the judges, kissing and hi-fiving along the way. But he ended the song, staring into Haley's eyes, singing "you're mine." Aww.

And then there were five. I'm a bit surprised to see Casey go before Jacob, but it seems gospel-soul resonates with viewers more that jazzy-blues this season. Or maybe Jacob wooed the fashionistas, wearing a suit louder than he is. What do you guys think?

Get more at TV Squad >>

Tags: Casey Abrams

Comments

(18)

Friday 29 April

By joe alvarez

Highest Rank Vote down Vote up Report this

I think the name of the show should be
changed to american Idol teenagers, these kids
bore me, just a thought.

By lisa

High Rank Vote down Vote up Report this

Jacob was sent to safety not Scotty. It was between Scotty and Casey not Jacob.

By gary954

Vote down Vote up Report this

Yeah but Jacob should have been sent packing!! The drag queen wanna be needs to leave!! Tired of seeing him wail every week!!!

By smiller

your recap is off a bit. scotty was not sent back swiftly to the seats. jacob was and the last two standing were scotty and casey. it was obvious at that point that it was casey going home. might want to change that.

By mbchowell1

Casey was annoying to listen to. Very talented but who knows what his "real" voice sounded like. Plus i think he was a little full of himself. Trying to appear all groovy and odd--he tried to hard. He shold have been eliminated when he sang that Nirvana song--I changed channels.

By Laurie

"What do you guys think?"

I think you should watch the show a little more closely. Jacob was sent to safety; it was Scotty who stood alone with Casey at the end. If it weren't for the over-the-top SNARK-fest here, this would be a decent recap.

By Julie

CRAP!!! I thought for sure it would be Casey and James in the final... James would of course win, but is disgusting that Casey went home before Jacob. My god he gets on my nerves, I cannot understand how the judges can be so in love with him.

By 9_9

Casey needs friggin laxatives. Awful to watch and listen. Terrible season.

By *M*

Jacob needs to go home already!!!!!

I agree! Get Jacob out of there!!

By Diana

Pia should have been the winner for American Idol. CASEY SHOULD HAVE BEEN IN THE FINAL 3. Obviously, letting the public choose is not the best way to choose the singing Idol. However, the show will continue to let the public vote because, among other things, it's a way to measure viewership. One person can vote 500 times or more in one night if they choose to. They should limit each person to one vote. That would be more fair.

By hltcs

Jacob should have been gone a long time ago. There's nothing about him that's appealing and I can't stand his voice. He shouldn't have even been in the top 11. I don't know what the judges are hearing when they say he has a beautiful voice, because I'm not hearing it.

By Willis Fraley

I am glad Casey is gone. He is no better than a club singer. same voice and no changes cost him this time. He growled to to much. like it was said. Dogs Dont vote for them people Do.

By Jimmy

America, I award you no points and may god have mercy on your soul! How did Casey go home before Meshell Ndegeocello, oops, I mean Jacob. He tries to mix the Winans with Donna Summer and fails at both! I'll definitely be waiting on Casey's album.

By simpsonsimpmike

They should have gotten ride of the fat gospel guy first he sucks

By J

This show should be entitled "America DOESN'T Know Talent". Casey was a great performer, stepping outside the pop music genre. There was actually depth & thought in his music unlike Country Girl and Country Boy. They need to be voted off immediately! I am amazed they have made it this far. I love country music; however, these two are good at best and are far more suited for county fairs. Country Boy sounds the same no matter what he is singing and with the weird facial movements & strange microphone technique...just odd. Country Girl is just way too immature and animiated like a child - not good. I hope at this point it will be between James & Haleigh.

By Bonbon

Shocker? He was already at the bottom four weeks ago when they wasted their save on him! Good riddence!

By Michael

I hardly think Casey is a "fan favorite" as the title of the article states. He's already been voted off once. Plus that poor boy was a decent singer who had no idea what kind of album he would release. I know you might say "jazz," but let's not forget Casey sang "Smells Like Teen Spirit" and a strange version of "Harder to Breathe." And, unfortunately, the judges weren't helping him by saying he could sing anything (while telling other contestants that they're in trouble if they don't pick a recordable genre and stick with it). Eventually, America was going to get confused with his constatly changing persona and get rid of him. He may be a nice guy, but so were Lee Dewyze, Kris Allen, Taylor Hicks, and Ruben Studdard. And none of their albums went anywhere either.

Page 1 of 1